Score computed from verified review sentiment, ingredient efficacy, and cross-platform consistency.
Reviewed by Flash AI Editorial Team · Last updated March 2026.
The RENEE Midnight Kohl Pencil delivers an intense, deep black pigment in a single swipe, allowing for bold eye looks and a dramatic finish that users find impressive.
The RENEE Midnight Kohl Pencil is formulated with Vitamin E, Castor Oil, and Olive Oil, which aim to nourish the delicate eye area while providing color, making it a more caring option for the eyes.
Users report that the RENEE Midnight Kohl Pencil glides on smoothly and effortlessly, providing a creamy texture that doesn't tug on the waterline or eyelids, making application easy.
The RENEE Midnight Kohl Pencil is described as waterproof, meaning it holds up well against water and does not easily wash off, which is a significant advantage for long-lasting wear.
Despite claims of being smudge-proof, some users found that the RENEE Midnight Kohl Pencil smudges on the eyelids due to the warmth and natural oils of the eye area, especially after a few hours of wear.
Some users reported feeling that the RENEE Midnight Kohl Pencil felt heavy on their eyes, potentially leading to discomfort, sleepiness, headaches, or watery eyes, which detracts from the overall wear experience.
The included sharpener with the RENEE Midnight Kohl Pencil has been reported as ineffective by some users, requiring them to purchase a separate sharpener to properly use the pencil.
Flash AI analyzes thousands of reviews across Amazon, Nykaa, YouTube & Reddit, etc. to give you one honest score — and finds you the best price in India.
The Renee Midnight Kohl Pencil in Brown is a waterproof, matte kajal built for precise eye definition on the waterline and lids. It comes in pencil format with a sharpener for maintaining a sharp, controlled tip. With an AI Score of 75/100 drawn from 1412 verified reviews across 5 platforms, this kajal earns high marks for Pigmentation (95) and Application (90), with Formula rated at 80. Its Wear score of 55 is the one number buyers should pay attention to before purchasing, as it reflects a real pattern in reviewer feedback around longevity.
The formula lists three key ingredients in the specs: Vitamin E, Castor oil, and Olive oil. Vitamin E is an antioxidant that helps protect the delicate skin of the eye area during daily wear. Castor oil contributes directly to the creamy, smooth texture that reviewers consistently describe as glide-on and non-tugging, making waterline application comfortable. Olive oil adds a conditioning layer to the base. These three work together to balance rich colour delivery with a formula gentler on the eye area than stripped-back wax-only alternatives. The pencil is cruelty-free and carries a shelf life of 36 months from the month of manufacturing.
This pencil suits those with dry to normal skin who want strong brown-toned definition and can work with occasional touch-ups. Reviewers with oily skin noted smudging on the eyelids after a few hours, with fading and messiness more pronounced in warm conditions. Some users reported a heavy sensation after extended wear, leading to discomfort, watery eyes, or headaches. The included sharpener has drawn consistent criticism for being ineffective, so budget for a separate one. A patch test is recommended before regular use, and anyone who develops rash, irritation, or itchiness should discontinue immediately.
The Renee Midnight Kohl Pencil in Brown is available from ₹360 to ₹485 across 15 sellers, making the entry price competitive for a daily-use kajal with a nourishing ingredient base. At ₹360, the strong pigmentation and smooth application scores make this a solid pick for value-conscious buyers who prioritise colour payoff. The Flash AI verdict: this pencil delivers well on what it promises for dry to normal skin types, but oily skin users should go in expecting touch-ups rather than all-day effortless wear. Buy from the lower end of the price range to get the most from a well-formulated, fairly priced kohl pencil.
"With a Flash AI Score of 75/100, Renee Midnight Kohl Pencil- Brown, One-swipe Waterproof, Smudge-proof Kajal - 1.5 G earns its ranking through demonstrated, cross-platform results."
— Flash AI Editorial TeamRenee is an Indian beauty brand offering a diverse range of cosmetics and skincare products, from long-wearing kajals and lip tints to collagen-infused sleeping masks. Known for their paraben-free and sulphate-free formulations, the brand focuses on accessible, everyday beauty essentials that prioritize skin hydration and nourishment. Renee products are widely available across major Indian marketplaces including Amazon, Flipkart, Myntra, and Nykaa.
| Features | Midnight Kohl Pencil- Brown, One-swipe | Staze All Eyes On You - Tubing Mascara | Sotrue Dark Spell Black Kohl Kajal | Maybelline New York Hypercurl Mascara |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Key Actives | Vitamin E, Olive oil, Castor oil | Tea Leaf Extract… | ||
| Best For | everyday makeup | Women | ||
| Fragrance | — | — | — | — |
| Price From | ₹360 | ₹261 | ₹279 | ₹251 |
"bought the RENEE Midnight Kajal because I was searching for a smudge-proof option, as kajal tends to spread quickly on my eyes. The reviews online suggested it was both smudge-proof and waterproof. I can confirm that it is definitely waterproof. Here’s my main observation: I noticed that when I tested it on my hand, it did not smudge. However, the experience was different on my eyes. The warmth and natural oils of my eyelids caused it to smudge and spread after just two or three hours of wear. So, while it looks promising on a simple patch test, it did not live up to the smudge-proof claim for my eye area. I wasn't particularly impressed with its staying power for all-day wear. However, if you're looking for a kajal that blends easily and is perfect for creating a smokey eye look, this could still be a good, affordable option for you to try!"
"bought the RENEE Midnight Kajal because I was searching for a smudge-proof option as kajal tends to spread quickly on my eyes.?The reviews online suggested ..."
"Nice brown kajal long lasting"
Apply the pencil directly to the upper or lower waterline using one smooth, controlled swipe. The creamy formula requires minimal pressure and glides without tugging. A freshly sharpened tip gives the most precise line, so sharpen before each use. Reviewers recommend keeping the tip sharp for consistent application, as the included sharpener may not always perform reliably.
The pencil is waterproof and claims smudge-proof wear for up to 24 hours, but reviewers with oily skin reported fading and messiness after several hours, particularly in warm or humid conditions. If your eyelids tend to be oily, you may need a mid-day touch-up. Dry to normal skin types are more likely to experience wear closer to the 24-hour claim.
Castor oil contributes to the pencil's creamy, smooth texture. It helps the formula glide onto the waterline and eyelids without dragging or tugging, which reviewers consistently highlight as one of the strongest aspects of the application experience. It works alongside Vitamin E and Olive oil to give the formula a nourishing base beyond basic colourant and wax.
Results are immediate. The brown kajal delivers a matte, defined eye look from the first swipe. Reviewers consistently highlight the strong, instant colour payoff as one of the pencil's standout qualities. Wear duration, however, depends on skin type: dry to normal skin holds the colour longer, while oily skin may see fading within a few hours.
The product is for external use only and the brand recommends a patch test before use. If rash, irritation, or itchiness develops at any point, discontinue use immediately. Some reviewers reported a heavy sensation and discomfort after prolonged wear, including watery eyes. Those with a history of eye sensitivity should test carefully before committing to daily use.
Unlike a basic kajal stick, the Renee Midnight Kohl Pencil includes Vitamin E, Castor oil, and Olive oil in its formulation, adding a nourishing element alongside colour. The pencil format also gives you more application precision than a flat stick, and it comes with a sharpener to maintain a fine tip. The pigmentation score of 95 suggests colour payoff that goes beyond what a standard entry-level kajal typically delivers.
The pencil is listed across 15 sellers, with prices starting from ₹360 and going up to ₹485. Checking multiple major Indian e-commerce and beauty retail platforms gives you the best chance of finding it at the lower end of that range. Prices vary by seller and depend on any active promotions at the time of purchase.
Reviewers describe the texture as creamy and smooth, with no dragging or tugging on the waterline or lids. The matte finish gives a defined, non-shiny look from the first application. Some users reported a heavy sensation after extended wear that led to discomfort over the course of a long day. Initial application, however, is described as comfortable for most users.
Castor oil and Olive oil are commonly used in eye-area cosmetic formulations and both appear in the product's official ingredient list. The pencil is specifically designed for eye use and is labelled for external use only. The specs do not state dermatologist testing. A patch test is recommended before regular use, especially for those with a history of eye sensitivity or allergies to plant-based oils.
Yes, the kohl pencil is designed for waterline application. The smooth, creamy formula glides on without tugging, and the waterproof claim means it holds up against moisture on the waterline. Reviewers report reliable performance there, though those with very watery eyes may notice some fading over time. Keeping the tip sharp helps maintain precision for a clean waterline application.