Score computed from verified review sentiment, ingredient efficacy, and cross-platform consistency.
Reviewed by Flash AI Editorial Team · Last updated March 2026.
This lip and cheek tint offers impressive longevity, with users reporting it stays put for 8-12 hours, even through meals and drinks, minimizing the need for frequent touch-ups throughout the day.
The tint provides a natural, blurred matte finish that looks like 'your skin but better' on both lips and cheeks, offering a fresh, dewy flush without feeling heavy or sticky.
The versatile formula can be used as both a lip tint and a cheek blush, providing a natural flush of color that is buildable and easy to blend for a fresh, everyday look.
The tint is praised for its buildable pigmentation, allowing users to achieve a sheer wash of color for a natural look or layer it for a bolder, more intense effect on lips and cheeks.
A significant number of users report the formula to be excessively sticky, feeling like glue on the lips, especially upon initial application or when layering for more pigment. This stickiness can persist even after drying.
The product can crumble and flake off the lips once dry, creating tiny pieces that stick to cups and utensils, leading to an unappealing appearance and a messy eating/drinking experience.
Removing the tint can be difficult, with some users finding that micellar water doesn't fully remove the product, particularly the sticky residue, requiring a more robust makeup remover.
Flash AI analyzes thousands of reviews across Amazon, Nykaa, YouTube & Reddit, etc. to give you one honest score — and finds you the best price in India.
The Maybelline New York Superstay Teddy Tint is a 5 ml liquid lip and cheek tint in the shade Pinkie Bestie, built to deliver a waterproof matte finish that holds for up to 12 hours. It earns an AI Score of 75 out of 100 on Flash AI, derived from 44 verified reviews across 5 platforms, with particularly strong scores in Longevity (90 out of 100) and Finish (85 out of 100). The dual-use formula applies to both lips and cheeks, giving you one product that covers two steps in your routine.
The Superstay Teddy Tint is a liquid formula with a matte finish, SPF 30, and a waterproof rating. It suits all skin types and carries vegan and cruelty-free certifications. The brand rates colour longevity at 12 hours. The 5 ml tube has a shelf life of 36 months. The shade Pinkie Bestie sits in the pink colour family and offers buildable application: a single light layer gives a sheer, natural flush, while additional layers build to a more saturated effect on both lips and cheeks.
People with oily to normal skin who want low-maintenance colour will find this tint a strong match. The waterproof formula and 12-hour wear hold through meals and drinks, and verified reviewers confirm this performance. The Comfort score of 65, however, reflects genuine concerns worth knowing before you buy. A significant portion of reviewers describe the formula as sticky, particularly during and immediately after application, with some reporting this stickiness persists even after the product sets. The tint can also flake once fully dry, which reviewers flag as a recurring issue. People with dry or chapped lips should approach with caution: reviewers report the matte formula worsens dryness and causes discomfort over time, even after prepping lips. Removing the tint fully requires a dedicated makeup remover, as micellar water may leave a sticky residue behind.
At ₹479 to ₹749 across 11 sellers, the Superstay Teddy Tint delivers genuine value if longevity and dual-use versatility are your priorities. The Longevity score of 90 and Finish score of 85 reflect real, verified performance on those fronts. But the Comfort score of 65 and consistent reviewer feedback about stickiness, flaking, and difficult removal make this a conditional recommendation. If you have oily to normal skin, want a single product for lips and cheeks, and are willing to use a proper makeup remover at the end of the day, picking this up at ₹479 from the lowest-priced seller gives you solid value.
"With a Flash AI Score of 75/100, Maybelline New York Superstay Teddy Tint Lip and Cheek Color Mascara Tear - 5 ml earns its ranking through demonstrated, cross-platform results."
— Flash AI Editorial TeamMaybelline New York is a globally recognised cosmetics brand offering an extensive range of makeup products, including lipsticks, mascaras, and lip colours. Known for its bold colour payoffs and long-wear formulas — particularly its Super Stay and Colossal lines — the brand delivers affordable, trend-forward makeup accessible to all. Maybelline New York products are widely available across major Indian marketplaces including Amazon, Nykaa, Flipkart, Myntra, Meesho, and Purplle.
"I’ve been using the Maybelline Teddy Tint in The A+ for a few weeks now and I’m honestly impressed. The color is this beautiful muted rose that looks super natural on both lips and cheeks. It gives that soft, blurred matte finish — very “your skin but better” kind of vibe. 💋 On the lips: It feels creamy at first and then sets into a comfortable matte and On the cheeks: It blends out like a dream and gives a really fresh, dewy flush. I love how it gives a natural glow without being heavy or sticky, amazing go for it girl"
"It is very tiny but with 1 swipe we will get the texture and finish nicely.It is very long lasting product and also easy to use.This shade is very nice suitable for all the skin types and giving a glow for the face but it is expensive.The texture of the lipstick is very sticky but also very smooth anyway I love the product very much☺️🤩. The lipstick shade is : Keep it cozy✨️.Very very nice shade🎀🦋✨️.Thank you soo much☺️🤩🦋✨️🤩."
"I absolutely loved the Maybelline SuperStay Teddy Tint! The shade is stunning and super flattering giving a natural yet polished look. The formula is ..."
Apply directly from the tube onto your lips, then dab a small amount onto your cheeks and blend with your fingertips. The formula is buildable, so start with a light layer for a natural flush and add more for deeper colour intensity. Fingertip blending works best on cheeks for the most natural matte finish.
Yes, the matte finish and waterproof formulation make this tint a practical choice for oily skin. The 12-hour wear rating and waterproof claim help colour stay in place throughout the day. Verified reviewers confirm the formula holds through meals and drinks without significant fading.
SPF 30 provides a base level of UV protection on the areas where you apply the tint. Lips are frequently skipped in sunscreen routines, making this a useful inclusion. That said, this tint is not a dedicated sunscreen and you should not rely on it as your sole source of sun protection.
The specs rate colour longevity at 12 hours. Verified reviewers back this up, reporting 8 to 12 hours of wear even through meals and drinks. Some reviewers note flaking once the formula fully sets, which can affect the appearance of the colour over an extended day.
This is a caution area. Multiple reviewers with dry lips found the matte formula worsens dryness and feels uncomfortable over time, even after prepping lips beforehand. If your lips are dry or chapped, this tint may not be your most comfortable daily option, and a hydrating lip product may suit you better.
Unlike a traditional lipstick, this is a liquid tint that also functions as a cheek blush, letting one product handle two steps in your routine. The matte finish blurs into skin rather than sitting on top of it, and the waterproof formula is rated for 12-hour wear. Standard lipsticks and powder blushes typically do not offer this combination of longevity, waterproofing, and dual-use application.
The Superstay Teddy Tint is available across 11 sellers, with prices starting at ₹479. Comparing listings across major Indian e-commerce and beauty platforms will help you find the most competitive current price.
Reviewers describe a soft, velvety feel once the tint dries down, with a blurred matte finish that reads as natural on both lips and cheeks. During and shortly after application, a sticky sensation is commonly reported. Once fully set, the colour holds well, though some reviewers document flaking over extended wear.
SPF 30 is a widely used protection factor in cosmetics and is broadly considered safe for daily use. This product is also vegan and cruelty-free per its specs, which means it avoids animal-derived ingredients. If you have specific sensitivities, check the full ingredient list before committing to daily use.
No, there is no mascara included. Despite the word appearing in the product listing name, this is a lip and cheek tint only. The 5 ml tube contains the Superstay Teddy Tint formula exclusively, designed for application on lips and cheeks.
Lemon8-App.Com
Amazon