Score computed from verified review sentiment, ingredient efficacy, and cross-platform consistency.
Reviewed by Flash AI Editorial Team · Last updated March 2026.
Users consistently praise the RENEE Midnight Kohl Pencil for its intense, jet-black pigmentation that delivers a bold look in a single swipe, making eyes appear more defined and alluring.
The RENEE Midnight Kohl Pencil is highly regarded for its smudge-proof and waterproof capabilities, with users reporting that it stays intact throughout the day, even through sweat and humidity, providing a long-lasting, clean look.
The RENEE Midnight Kohl Pencil offers a smooth, creamy texture that glides effortlessly across the eyelids without tugging, making application easy and comfortable, even for those with sensitive eyes.
The RENEE Midnight Kohl Pencil is enriched with Vitamin E, Castor Oil, and Olive Oil, which contribute to its nourishing properties and ensure it's safe for sensitive eyes, preventing irritation.
Some users have reported that the pencil can break easily after sharpening, leading to a hollow pencil design and concerns about the overall quality and potential for wasted product.
A significant drawback reported by some users is that the included sharpener does not effectively sharpen the pencil, leading to frustration and the need to purchase an alternative sharpener to use the product.
Despite its smudge-proof claims, some users have experienced the kajal smudging quickly, with one user reporting it smudged within an hour, suggesting it may not perform as expected for all users or under all conditions.
Flash AI analyzes thousands of reviews across Amazon, Nykaa, YouTube & Reddit, etc. to give you one honest score — and finds you the best price in India.
The Renee Midnight Kohl Pencil is a 1.5g eye pencil built for intense black definition on the waterline, lash line, and lids. It carries a matte finish, a waterproof and smudge-proof formula, and claims up to 24 hours of colour longevity. It scores 78/100 on Flash AI, drawn from 1,412 verified reviews across 5 platforms. The score reflects a strong Pigmentation rating of 95 and Longevity at 85, with Application at 80 and Comfort trailing at 65, a detail worth noting before purchase.
The formula centres on Dimethicone as a silicone base that enables smooth, drag-free application. Trimethyl Siloxysilicate and Phenyl Propyldimethyl Siloxysilicate are film-forming silicones that create a water-resistant layer once applied, keeping colour locked in place. Synthetic wax gives the pencil tip structural hold and supports smudge-proof performance. Tocopheryl Acetate, a stable form of Vitamin E, adds antioxidant support and a nourishing quality to daily eye use. Phenoxyethanol and Caprylyl Glycol function as preservatives. The pigment blend may include CI 77499 (iron oxide black), CI 77266 (carbon black), and CI 77510 (ultramarine blue), working together to produce the deep, intense black tone this kajal is known for. The formula is paraben-free, vegan, and cruelty-free.
This pencil suits anyone who needs high-pigment, long-wear kohl for daily use, particularly those dealing with humidity, sweat, or oily lids. The creamy glide makes it accessible for beginners and those with sensitive eyes. That said, two recurring concerns appear across reviews: the pencil tip can break when sharpening, and the built-in sharpener is frequently criticised for being ineffective. Some users report smudging within an hour under certain conditions, suggesting performance is not universal. A smaller group finds the product feels heavy on the eyes, causing watery eyes or discomfort during extended wear. Those with known eye sensitivity should approach with caution.
Flash AI verdict: at ₹337, the Renee Midnight Kohl Pencil delivers strong value. The Pigmentation score of 95 and Longevity score of 85 align with what verified reviewers consistently report, a bold, lasting kajal that holds through a full day. The top end of ₹1,119 across 13 sellers is harder to justify. Stick to sellers priced near ₹337 for the best return. If you want intense black eye definition that survives humidity and daily activity, this is a reliable choice at the lower price point. If you depend on the included sharpener or have significant eye sensitivity, factor those limitations into your decision.
"With a Flash AI Score of 78/100, Renee Midnight Kohl Pencil - Smudgeproof and Waterproof Kajal - 1.5 GM earns its ranking through demonstrated, cross-platform results."
— Flash AI Editorial TeamRenee is an Indian beauty brand offering a diverse range of cosmetics and skincare products, from long-wearing kajals and lip tints to collagen-infused sleeping masks. Known for their paraben-free and sulphate-free formulations, the brand focuses on accessible, everyday beauty essentials that prioritize skin hydration and nourishment. Renee products are widely available across major Indian marketplaces including Amazon, Flipkart, Myntra, and Nykaa.
| Features | Midnight Kohl Pencil - Smudgeproof | Staze All Eyes On You - Tubing Mascara | Sotrue Dark Spell Black Kohl Kajal | Maybelline New York Hypercurl Mascara |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Key Actives | Dimethicone, Synthetic wax, Trimethyl Siloxysilicate, Phenyl Propyldimethyl Siloxysilicate, Phenoxyethanol, Caprylyl Glycol, Tocopheryl Acetate, May Contain: CI 77499, CI 77266, CI 77510 | Tea Leaf Extract… | ||
| Best For | everyday makeup | Women | ||
| Fragrance | — | — | — | — |
| Price From | ₹337 | ₹261 | ₹279 | ₹251 |
"I recently tried the RENEE Midnight Kohl Kajal and I'm impressed! The intense black pigment delivers a bold dramatic look that lasts all day. It's ..."
"bought the RENEE Midnight Kajal because I was searching for a smudge-proof option as kajal tends to spread quickly on my eyes.?The reviews online suggested ..."
"This kajal is really smooth and glides effortlessly on the eyes. The pigmentation is rich giving a bold black color in just one stroke. It stays smudge ..."
You can use it daily. Apply directly to the upper or lower lash line or waterline with light, short strokes. The creamy texture delivers bold colour in a single swipe, so heavy layering is not necessary. Starting from the inner corner and working outward gives the most even result.
The specs list it as suitable for all skin types, and reviewers regularly use it on the waterline. The waterproof and smudge-proof formula helps it stay in place through the day. However, some users report watery eyes or heaviness with extended wear, so those with sensitive eyes should monitor their reaction during initial use.
Tocopheryl Acetate is a stable, oil-soluble form of Vitamin E. In this formula, it acts as an antioxidant and contributes a nourishing quality to daily eye application. It supports skin health in the delicate eye area, making the product more comfortable for regular use.
Reviewers report that the colour appears bold and intense from the first application. The smudge-proof properties set quickly once applied. The specs cite up to 24 hours of colour longevity, and the Flash AI Longevity score of 85 reflects strong reviewer sentiment on wear time, though individual results can vary by skin type and environmental conditions.
Performance varies by individual. Some users report that the pencil feels heavy on the eyes, leading to watery eyes or headaches during extended wear. While the specs note it suits all skin types, those with a history of eye sensitivity should do a short wear test before committing to all-day use. If irritation persists, discontinue use.
Unlike a standard kajal, the Renee Midnight Kohl Pencil uses silicone film formers, specifically Trimethyl Siloxysilicate and Phenyl Propyldimethyl Siloxysilicate, that create a water-resistant barrier once set. This gives it a clear longevity advantage in humid weather or during physical activity. The formula's synthetic wax component also reinforces its smudge-proof behaviour, which a basic kajal formulation typically does not offer.
This product is available across 13 sellers, with prices ranging from ₹337 to ₹1,119. For the best value, compare prices across major Indian retail platforms before purchasing. Buying from a seller at or near ₹337 gives you the strongest return relative to the product's performance profile.
The pencil has a smooth, creamy texture that glides across the eye area without tugging or dragging. Reviewers consistently describe the application as effortless, even on sensitive or dry eyelids. The finish is matte with no shimmer or gloss, and the colour reads as a deep, saturated black from the first stroke.
The formula is paraben-free, vegan, and cruelty-free. It uses Dimethicone, silicone-based film formers, and Tocopheryl Acetate, all widely accepted in cosmetic formulations for eye products. Phenoxyethanol and Caprylyl Glycol are included as preservatives and are considered standard in cosmetic use. If you have known sensitivities to any listed ingredient, consult a dermatologist before committing to daily use.
The product includes a built-in sharpener, but a significant number of reviewers report it is ineffective and can cause the tip to snap. For better results, use a separate eye pencil sharpener with a wider barrel suited to soft kajal pencils. Sharpen slowly in short, gentle rotations and avoid applying pressure, as the creamy formula makes the tip more prone to breaking.
Amazon